Emily Orsini, Managing Editor

In its regular-season finale on Nov. 14, not only did the Denison football team face a formidable foe, but they also faced a familiar face. 

The Big Red lost to host John Carroll 38-6 to end the year at 6-4 overall and 6-3 in the NCAC, finishing fourth in-conference. 

The stakes were high going into this game— a victory would extend the Big Red’s season, giving them the chance to be eligible for a bowl game, as well as defeat an NCAC powerhouse that recorded an undefeated in-conference season in 2025. 

And lining up at quarterback for the Blue Streaks was Tyler Green ‘28, who played his first two seasons at Denison. 

During his time on The Hill, Green established himself as one of Division III’s premier quarterbacks. Last season he led the nation in completions per game (30.7) and was second in passing yards (3,440) and passing yards per game (344).

“I know Tyler will probably try to say this was just another game, but it’s not,” said JCU head coach and director of athletics, Brian Polian. “To say that he knows those other guys and that this is going to be just another game, that’s unrealistic to say that.” 

John Carroll has proven itself as a powerhouse in Division III football, compiling a 52-14 record over the past five seasons and earning an NCAA playoff berth in 2025.

“The mindset before the game was we have a chance to play in the bowl game if we can get a win up there,” said Jack Hatem, Denison’s head football coach. “We know they have a very talented roster, and obviously physical size and speed. 

“But exactly what you would have wanted our guys to do is what they did. They played really hard. We gave them all they could handle, I think, for a long time in that game. 

And I’m really proud of that.”

The Big Red stayed close the first half, trailing 7-0 at the break.

“This league is really good,” said Polian. “I think Denison is very unique in what they do and they’re really smart in what they do…I have a lot of respect for the players and coaches in this league.”

Although John Carroll pulled away in the second half, the significance of the matchup to Green wasn’t lost on the coaching staff.

“I was talking to [Green] after the game last weekend on Saturday, like ‘hey, my man, we’ve got to control this week,’” said Polian.

“The conversation with him was ‘hey listen, we’re just going to go play our game. It will come to you. Don’t worry about it. Just take a breath.’ 

“It felt like everyday I was checking in with him and stressed, ‘you good?’ and he was like, ‘I’m good’.”  

Hatem had a different approach with his squad.

“I didn’t talk with the team about Tyler last week. I felt like that was the wrong thing to do,” said Hatem. 

“It’s the world we live in right now. I don’t really hold it against young people for [transferring]. If [athletes] feel like they can improve themselves financially, or opportunity wise, that’s the choice they make.”

That sentiment was echoed by Green, who expressed nothing but appreciation for his former program.

“Nothing but love for those people,” said Green. “They’ve shown me nothing but respect.”

Hatem said he was pleased with the performance of the Big Red, who will graduate 19 seniors.

“This is probably the most challenging schedule we’ve ever played in the history of the school. And we knew that going in,” said Hatem. 

“But that being said, we beat our rivals. We won five games at home. It was a really, really solid year. I’m very confident in this team, and what they’re going to do in the offseason.”